illegitimate – Discipline & Punish http://blogs.elsweb.org/disciplinepunish Early American Crime Narratives Wed, 20 Jun 2007 01:23:10 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.3.2 Elizabeth Wilson http://blogs.elsweb.org/disciplinepunish/elizabeth-wilson-4/ Wed, 20 Jun 2007 01:23:10 +0000 http://blogs.elsweb.org/disciplinepunish/2007/06/19/elizabeth-wilson-4/ Continue reading ]]> Alibi- Elizabeth Wilson is the only person in one of these narratives to proclaim her innocence and have a plausible alibi. When accused of murdering her twins, Wilson “persisted in denying the fact; her behavior was such, in general, as gave reason to conclude she was innocent of the murder of which she was charged, or was an insensible, hardened creature, and did not expect to die for this crime.” The narrative is intended more as a tear-jerker than a cautionary tale. The state is in the wrong here. Foucault said that public executions began to work against the church and state because they began to engender sympathy for the murdered or bloodlust. Here, we can see how a public execution could backfire and reflect poorly on the state rather than the sinner.

Happy-  Wilson supposedly says that the dungeon is “the happiest place she ever was in her life.”  This seems strange and unlikely because she is in jail falsely accused of murdering her children.   This sounds like the religious propaganda found mostly in earlier narratives.

Marriage-  The sacrament of marriage is important in these texts.  A big deal is made of whether children are legitimate or illegitimate.  Wilson, like Charlotte Temple, is seduced by the promise of marriage.   The involvement of the church is important.  This narrative seems to be warning women (as C.T. did) that a promise of marriage was not the same thing as marriage.  Men are fallible; the church is not.

]]>
Monster http://blogs.elsweb.org/disciplinepunish/monster/ Tue, 22 May 2007 22:22:43 +0000 http://blogs.elsweb.org/disciplinepunish/2007/05/22/monster/ Continue reading ]]> Monster: A creature whose identity is created (or distorted) by the imagination or legend.

 

The behavior of gang members is like a legend based on distant stories that becomes real to the people working in the prison system. Monster seems to be an apt name for the author because, as a gang member, he is treated as something dangerous and inhuman. The officers retaliate disproportionately to his disobedient acts because they are afraid of something vague and intangible. According to Monster, their fear extends beyond gang members to young black men in general.

Illegitimate: Something that is not accepted by the mainstream or does not fit into the usual processes of a culture.

 

Monster is not accepted by his “father” because he is illegitimate. Although he grows up with Scott, Scott is unwilling to accept him as his child because it culturally unacceptable to embrace a child that was born of an affair. Later he finds it easier to adapt to an illegitimate living and join a gang than to be successful the legitimate way. Because he is poor, it would be difficult for him to get the college education which would enable him to get a good job. The book suggests that white people, who comprise the majority of society, are afraid of young black men and gang members. If this is true, it becomes nearly impossible for him to make a legal living once he becomes involved in a gang and goes to jail.

 

Misrule: Governance that comes to resemble anarchy because it is misguided.

 

All the groups of Crips follow strict rules, but they lead to civil war among the Crips. In jail, the different groups of Crips are still fighting even though there are few of them and they have other enemies that want to kill them. Even among the Crips that want to unite, the leadership is conflicted and Monster realizes that it is flawed and self-destructive.

 

]]>